Home How to Replace a Toilet in 12 Steps

How to Replace a Toilet in 12 Steps

Last updated:

Old toilet tipped on its side with the outlet exposed

Toilets are among the most durable fixtures in the bathroom, but a cracked bowl or tank can mean it’s time for a new one. You may also want a model that uses less water. If your existing toilet experiences clogging toilet issues, check whether the drain is clear before buying a replacement. A blockage in the drain line needs clearing first.

If you’re learning how to replace a toilet, start by measuring for a floor-mounted model that fits the existing outlet. Once the old toilet is out, you can check the flange and test-fit the bowl before you open the new seal.

Tools and materials

Gather work gloves, safety glasses, a tape measure, a small level, a bucket, a sponge, a putty knife, a utility knife, an adjustable wrench, tongue-and-groove pliers, and a small hacksaw if the old nuts are rusted in place. Set aside towels and cardboard to protect the floor when you lift the toilet.

Have the new toilet, closet bolts and hardware, a seal that suits the flange height, and plastic toilet shims on hand. Check the box for the seat, the seal, and any mounting adapter. If you need a supply connector, match both fittings and pick a length that reaches without pulling or bending sharply. Keep a drain plug and any caulk called for in the installation instructions nearby.

Illustrated 12-step toilet replacement guide with tools and materials

How to Replace a Toilet?

These 12 steps cover a standard floor-outlet toilet. Read the sheet for your model first, especially if the base hides the bolts or uses a separate drain adapter. Ask someone to help lift a one-piece toilet or a heavy bowl, and clear a spot to set it down.

Step 1: Take measurements for the new toilet

To measure the toilet rough-in, hold your tape perpendicular to the finished wall behind the toilet. Measure to the center of either closet bolt at the base, using the wall surface above the baseboard. If the old toilet is already off, measure to the center of the floor opening. A 12-inch rough-in is common, and 10- and 14-inch models are also available. Check the drawing for the exact model before ordering. A measurement just under 12 inches may leave too little room behind some tanks.

Tape measure aligned with the center of a toilet flange

If you’re figuring out how to replace a toilet in a small bathroom, check the new bowl’s full depth against the door swing and the space in front. Check the side clearance, where the shutoff valve sits, and whether you can still reach it with a skirted base in place. Compare the new base footprint with the old one, especially if the old flooring ends right at the base.

Some units come with a round bowl, while others have an elongated design. Round bowls can save space. If you’re buying the seat separately, measure the toilet seat by checking the bowl shape and hinge-bolt spacing. That measurement is separate from the floor rough-in.

Step 2: Shut off the water and disconnect the supply line

Close the toilet shutoff valve by hand. A multi-turn knob closes clockwise, while a quarter-turn lever moves 90 degrees to the closed position. If the bowl is at its usual level and drains freely, flush once and hold the handle down to empty most of the tank. If the bowl is high or clogged, scoop the tank water into a bucket and remove the bowl water separately.

Wait and watch for refilling. If the shutoff is stuck or lets water through, turn off the main supply if you can do so safely. Confirm the flow has stopped before loosening the hose. Use a shallow pan underneath and disconnect the supply line at the tank. The hose can still drip after the tank is empty.

Open toilet tank showing the fill valve and overflow tube

Faucet supply hoses attached beneath a sink
Faucet supply fittings. On the toilet, find the supply line at the single inlet beneath the tank.

Step 3: Remove the mounting nuts

Pry the caps off the floor bolts and remove the nuts and washers. The bolt heads can stay in the flange until the bowl is off. If a nut is seized, use a small hacksaw on the exposed bolt below the nut if you can reach it without hitting the porcelain or floor. Cut through any caulk around the base with a utility knife before you try to lift the bowl.

Step 4: Uninstall the toilet tank and bowl

Before lifting, see how water can drain from the tank and bowl and sponge out any water you can still reach. On a two-piece toilet, it’s often easier to unbolt the tank and lift it off first. Gently rock the old bowl to release the wax seal, then lift it straight up with a helper if needed. Keep it upright and set it on cardboard or in a shallow tray. Water can still spill from inside the trap if you tip the bowl.

Person lifting a detached toilet tank

If your bolts are stuck or the bowl won’t release, see how to remove a toilet from the floor for the full removal sequence.

Step 5: Remove the old wax ring

Cover the drain opening while you work. Use a removable drain plug or a rag large enough to pull back out. Scrape the old wax off the flange with a putty knife. If the old bowl is going back in, clear the wax from its outlet too. Once you lift a toilet off a wax seal, that seal needs replacing.

Wiping old wax from the toilet flange

Step 6: Inspect and repair the flange

Check whether the flange is firmly anchored. Look for cracks, badly corroded metal, loose screws, and bolt slots that no longer hold the bolt heads. A compatible repair ring can restore damaged bolt slots if the flange body and the surrounding floor are sound. If the flange body is cracked or loose at the drain, you may need to repair the drain connection as part of changing the old toilet flange. Address a soft or water-damaged subfloor before the bowl goes back down.

Lay a straightedge over the finished floor to see how high or low the sealing surface sits. Match it to the seal or flange extender instructions. If new flooring has left the flange recessed, a compatible extender or a seal rated for that gap can restore the fit. If the flange stands so high that the bowl rests on it and rocks, correct the flange height first.

Repair ring held over a worn toilet flange

Step 7: Install new toilet bolts

Slide the bolt heads into the flange slots opposite each other. Use the retainers from the kit if supplied to keep the bolts upright. The bolts should line up with the holes in the bowl and stay put as you lower it. The washers and nuts that hold the bowl down go on after the toilet is set.

Closet bolts positioned beside a blue toilet seal

Step 8: Test-fit the new toilet

When you’re learning how to replace a toilet, a dry fit is a good way to catch problems while the seal is still in the package. Remove the temporary drain cover and lower the bowl over the bolts without a seal. Check that the base sits on the floor, the bolts pass through freely, and the tank will clear the wall. Use a level across the rim and check for rocking by pressing lightly on either side.

If a firm but slightly uneven floor leaves a small gap, mark where plastic toilet shims make the bowl stable. Pick the bowl back up and cover the drain again until you’re ready to set the seal. If the porcelain hits the flange or the outlet doesn’t line up with the floor opening, fix that before you compress the seal.

Test-fitting the toilet bowl beside a bathroom vanity

Step 9: Set the new seal

Remove the temporary drain plug or rag. For wax, center one new ring on the clean flange or on the bowl outlet, as directed for your toilet and seal. If the gap is outside the ring’s recommended range, correct the flange height first. Some wax-free seals use a spacer or a specific orientation, so follow that kit’s instructions for the height you measured. Have a spare wax ring nearby in case you need to lift and reset the bowl.

New wax ring with a plastic guide sleeve

Step 10: Install the new toilet

Lower the bowl straight down over the bolts. If you marked shim positions during the dry fit, have those shims ready where the base needs support. Press down evenly to seat the seal. Keep the bowl aligned as it settles. If you lift the bowl again after it compresses a wax ring, use a fresh ring before resetting it.

On a two-piece toilet, set the bowl first. If you’re moving a heavier one-piece toilet, have your helper guide the bolts into the base while you lower it together.

Step 11: Tighten the nuts

Fit the cap bases, washers, and nuts in the order shown in your model’s instructions. Alternate sides in small turns until the bowl sits firmly. Tightening hard to pull down a rocking bowl can crack the porcelain. Check the shims and floor contact if it still moves. Fit the bolt caps once both sides are snug.

Closet bolt with a washer and nut at the toilet base

Step 12: Connect the water and test for leaks

On a two-piece toilet, mount the tank with its supplied gasket and bolts. Tighten the tank hardware as directed for the model. Thread the supply connector on squarely by hand, then follow its instructions for tightening. Open the shutoff slowly, let the tank fill, and check for drips before the first flush. Start with a dry floor. Use a dry paper towel to check both ends of the hose, the shutoff valve, and the underside of the tank. Check the tank bolts and the tank-to-bowl joint on a two-piece toilet.

When the supply and tank are dry, flush several times and let the tank refill between flushes. Watch the floor at the base and check behind the bowl, where a tank leak can run down onto the floor. If the supply drips, close the shutoff before touching the connection. If water appears at floor level during a flush and the fittings above stay dry, stop using the toilet and trace the leak at the base. A misaligned seal or damaged flange can mean lifting the bowl and fitting a fresh seal.

Fit the seat using its mounting instructions. If you want to replace the new toilet seat with a different style, match it to the shape and the hinge holes. Once the toilet is stable and dry through the tests, finish the base with any caulk called for in the instructions and observe the label’s cure time.

Summary

When you’re learning how to replace a toilet, remember to check the fit while the seal is still unused. Once the bowl sits steady and the new seal is in place, check for leaks with a full tank and again while flushing.

If your existing toilet is sound and the trouble is limited to refilling the tank, a part replacement may be enough. See How to change a toilet fill valve?

Still have a question about how to replace a toilet? Comment below.

Hi, this is Robert Crossan, the owner of this website, has 17 years of experience in the installation, maintenance, and repair of toilets and plumbing systems. After completing the Level 2 Basic Plumbing course in 2005, I started working in both domestic and commercial buildings as a professional plumber. So I can figure out the core difference between different toilet models and brands. It also helped me monitor their work performance and setbacks.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here